A version of this post was first published on my personal blog in May 2010.
I love my firstborn, Mason. I love him with a ferocity that is both grand and fragile as glass — and sometimes, that love just shatters into a million pieces of shards that stick right into my heart and make me feel like my whole body might explode from the emotion of it all. Mason was my colicky baby, my only tantrum-prone toddler so far, a child who has defied and challenged me his entire existence in one way or another. He’s the most like me — the result of my mother’s long-ago curse that I might have a child “just like me” — and he’s the most maddening, complex puzzle I have ever faced. I love him, I fear him, I am in awe of him. It’s quite a motherhood emotional cocktail.
Last Wednesday, Mason pushed my every button. It amazes me that even now my children can act as if I just came up with this whole “you have to get ready for school” business on a spontaneous whim. Like, I will remind them to go brush their teeth, and I am received with a primitive wail, a drop to the knees, and a “Whyyyyyyyyy do we have to brush our teeeeeeeeth?!” as if we haven’t done it for years now. They “forget” to pick up their backpacks, they “forget” to eat their breakfast until the minute we need to walk out the door (at which time they declare themselves “starving” and whinge about how they might fall over from hunger if they must take a step more), and they always “forget” their socks and shoes. It’s like Groundhog Day every day — they never seem better prepared for the process than they were the day before.
Mason, at age seven, adds a layer of attitude to that selective ignorance, and he gives it to me liberally. He ignores me, he backtalks me, he leads the others like Lost Boys into the Land of Naughtiness. Wednesday was unremarkable in that it was checkered with me having to remind them many times to do each and every step of the morning process, but for whatever reason, I was stressed and at the end of my fuse even more than usual. When I finally herded all three boys upstairs for the dreaded Brushing of the Teeth, Mason ushered Ben, age two, aside and started urging him to throw toys down the stairs instead of following me for his brushing.
Well, that did it. We’ve had maybe four thousand speeches in this household about the stairs: Don’t Play on the Stairs, Don’t Throw Things Down the Stairs, Don’t Show Your Little Brother Anything Having to Do with Standing at the Top of the Stairs. It’s a common theme, as I am pretty sure we are due for at least one tumble-down-the-stairs incident any time now. When Mason started chucking random toys down the stairwell gleefully and encouraged his littlest brother to follow suit, he chucked my last nerve down the stairs with the toys.
I screamed at him. I never, ever thought I would scream at my children. I certainly never thought, when I slept for sixteen weeks in a La-Z-Boy using my nipples as pacifiers for a wailing and inconsolable baby because I loved him just that desperately much, that I would find myself holding that same baby by his pointy, gangly shoulder blades and scream at him like some wild-haired banshee. “What have I told you about the stairs?!” I screeched, even in the moment wondering when I became Mommie Dearest. But I couldn’t stop. I was so overtaken by my everything that I just completely lost it. I had dropped my emotional basket.
He just laughed nervously back, refusing to show me any real fear or remorse, never answering my question. I screamed until I couldn’t scream anymore, until my throat burned and my voice became hoarse from the effort, and we picked ourselves up, both exhausted, and the four of us walked quietly to the car and left for the school.
I was a broken woman. The shame and the guilt and the frustration hunched my back and burned in the back of my throat like bile.
The boys had school chapel that day. Charlie, the Kindergartner, wanted me to come to chapel so he could sit with me and Ben instead of his teachers. But Ben was unusually feisty, and I was worried we wouldn’t make it through the ceremony without a scene. I asked Charlie if I could just drop him off that one day and skip chapel instead. He started to cry. Resigned, I decided to walk over and give Mason a conciliatory hug where he sat with his class in the pews, just in case I had to leave in a hurry mid-service. When I did, his teacher caught my eye. “We had a rough morning,” I whispered in explanation. She pulled me aside. “I have to tell you,” she said under her breath, “he must save it for you. He’s always perfectly behaved in class. He’ll just sit and read at his desk with chaos going on around him.”
I know she meant her words to make me feel better, but instead, it just unhooked the latch to the dam. I burst into tears, standing right there in the middle of the church, my toddler hurtling his small body over the tops of the pews, my six-year-old looking around for me anxiously. Other parents glanced over and caught my wet eyes. I couldn’t stop crying. I just looked at his teacher with a weak smile and said, “He’s just… hard on me. I just don’t know how to parent him sometimes.” I bowed my head, grabbed Ben, and scrambled back to the Kindergarten section to take my seat with Charlie, embarrassed by my uncontrollable tears.
My turmoil that morning was not about teeth-brushing or hurling toys down the stairs. It was about the pile-on of the whole motherhood thing — the combination of feeling like nothing I say is ever catalogued or imbued with any substance, that I never feel like my children are safe, that life is about me constantly running lists in my head (will they have more cavities? are their uniform shirts clean? is the homework done? will they eat the lunches I made? will they fall down the stairs when I am not looking? will I step on a toy on my way down the stairs and trip and drop the toddler? will we be late… again?) and waiting for the other shoe to drop. I keep wondering when I will feel like I get to be on the same team as my children, when I don’t have to be the pain in the neck, nagging mom. When I get to drop the title of Fun Sponge of the Universe. When I get to lay this weight down, just for a minute. Because it is heavy.
Every day, I never, ever feel like I did it perfectly. Or even close. I wonder how much I am screwing them up and how much better could I be doing as a mother. And on a day when I break and scream at my seven-year-old firstborn child, I see just how very much I can screw up, how much damage I can do. I knew for sure I that I had failed that morning as spectacularly as I could have failed. It almost felt liberating.
After chapel, a friend of mine — another mom — texted me. “Are you okay?” the text asked. I called her. I cried. We agreed: this motherhood thing? Not for sissies.
That’s the truth. Being a mother takes a hell of a lot of courage. That doesn’t seem right, because it’s not like pre-mama me said, “I am going to be really brave and… have a baby!” I had no idea. I blindly (some would say stupidly) walked into motherhood. I thought it would be fun — almost indulgent. Some days — most days — are fun or indulgent in some way. But every day takes courage, whether I knew it or not when I signed on, because I have three pieces of my beating heart walking around outside my body — three little guys who could break my heart into a thousand, trillion pieces at the drop of a hat — and nothing is guaranteed. Every day is an adventure, and some days, like last Wednesday, are bonafide FAILS. The kids hurt themselves, they are hurt by others, they could hurt someone else, they are out and about in a world I don’t trust. They might grow up and break my heart over and over, as teenagers and beyond. It doesn’t matter how devotedly I do this mother thing, how hard I work, how much sweat and blood and tears I divulge; I cannot control them, I cannot control their fates. All I can control is how much I love them and how much I show it.
So many mothers are going through so many tragic, heartbreaking journeys right this very moment. They are facing health issues of their own, or their spouses’, or their children’s. They are worrying about money, about social issues, about the future. Their courage is worn right on their faces. But it doesn’t matter if we are going through something monumental or something mundane. Motherhood takes courage. It’s so. stupid. hard. Some days it takes courage just to throw my leg over the side of the bed and climb out, and I am not dealing with any of those special hurdles — just the run-of-the-mill, vanilla, First World, everyday hurdles. Even so, some days I just fail, and the worst part is, I know those days will happen. I know it, and I have to do it anyway.
It’s so stupid hard. But it’s all that matters. Don’t fool yourselves — we mothers, we’re made of strong stuff. Strong, imperfect stuff. I hope, and I have faith, that will be enough.
As the mother of a toddler for the first time, this came at a perfect time. Just remember….we are all in it together and the best things in life never come easy. Take care of yourself. -ab
I feel like this on the days I’ve screamed at my firstborn, and it was frequent these past few months. I have come to the point when I told my husband that this mothering thing just makes me feel sick, like a failure and maybe these children are better off in daycare. Because they don’t need a screaming mother who afterward, feels guilty all day. Sigh.
You’re right, this motherhood thing, it’s stupid hard. It’s not for the weak!
SO well said. Thank you for putting into words what I feel often! It IS stupid scary to think we are responsible for raising these little humans and what we do, say and act like now, will one day cultivate in them. Thank you for writing this 🙂
I love you. I love that I read what you write and it is almost always as if you are inside my head and hearing my thoughts, fears, joys, sorrows, and triumphs. This is all so very stupid hard. But it is also so ridiculously rewarding. My heart shrinks and swells many times a day with my most important endeavor. Thanks for being an inspiration to me.
I scream. I yell. Sometimes it’s inside my head. Most of the times. My children rarely hear it. I contain it.
But there are days where I don’t. And I let them know that I am not amused. That I am tired. That I NEED them to know that mommy is human and would they please, please, please just maybe stop being soooo, soooo….
I don’t know. Whatever they are being just sooooo much of at that moment.
Parenting is hard. There are few breaks. But I love it, I love them and I forgive myself, I forgive them.
None of us is perfect and we are finding our way together.
For now, that’s not perfect. But it’s enough.
Kiran
I found your blog through ADR and I’m so glad I did. You are such a great writer. And you wrote about my day last week, about my own 7 year old, so perfect at school and so difficult at home his dad had to carry him home from the park kicking and screaming last night. . He has been talking back to me and last Friday I lost it and screamed at him to stop. I felt so guilty I thought I ruined Christmas. Thank you for writing this and helping me to forgive myself. My second son is easy always, piece of cake. But someone once told me my oldest is the child i was meant to have.
Thank you again!
I too hear over and over again how wonderful my child is in school. How helpful and kind and sweet. And then she comes home and it’s like she’s forgotten. As much as I hate to say it — I’m glad to know that I’m not the only mom who screams at her children on occasion. It is a tough gig… but when you get those butterfly kisses and monkey hugs it’s so worth it!!!
Thank you thank you for sharing and expressing what it is to be a mother. Your words ring true for me and it’s nice to know I am in good company!! 🙂